Add Your Review

Thanks for visiting Mill Creek Cafe. We'd love to have your feedback!

Don't remember the name of your dish? Find it on our menu!

By submitting, you agree to our , and .

Our Latest Reviews

Mallen2 6 days ago

chicken, steak, shrimp, veggie, or surf-n-turf (steak and shrimp)

I had the power bowl with chicken and it did not disappoint! So delicious, filling, and satisfying! Great option if you want something healthy but not feeling a salad, even though their salads looked great too. Not only was the food great but the staff was super friendly, down to earth, and welcoming. Definitely will be making another trip soon!

Loulou 10 days ago

Mill Creeks Turkey Chili

The turkey chili convinced me to try using turkey instead of beef at home in my chili. It is a great bowl of chili served in a cute little cast iron pan with house made tortilla chips on the side. Delicious!

Guest 11 days ago

Grilled chicken, Sauted veggie, Slow roasted pork, Shaved steak, Brisket, Grilled shrimp, or Grilled Aukra Salmon

One of my normal "Go to" on the menu. Great flavor, filling and overall delicious!

Guest 12 days ago

Grass Fed Hamburger or Cheeseburger

Best burger 🍔, usually get the mexically with guacamole, sour cream, and salsa 💃!!!! 😋 with the hand 🖐 cut fries !!!!!! My go to meal!!!! And shout out to Caleb... great guy!

Mdallas23 14 days ago

Eggplant Parmesan Stackers

I'm not sure that having to pick one dish is fair. There are so many great dishes at the mill! Do yourself a favor and just go experience it for yourself, you won't regret it, I promise! Caleb and the crew are very attentive and never disappoint on the service end.

Phanafin81 29 days ago

Mill Creeker Quesadilla

Mill Creek Cafe is fantastic. Everytime I visit the area, I make sure to stop in. Have never been disappointed with any of their menu options. They are also very accommodating to all diets. Would highly recommend the visit!

Svanbure about 1 month ago

Mexicali Burger

Always perfect! Best French fries around!

Desireecollister113 about 2 months ago

Southwest Black Bean Burger

I've enjoyed eating at Millcreek for the past 6 years! Every experience I've had has been great. The Black bean burger is one of my favorites. Their fries are delicious too! 💗🥰

Kristie about 2 months ago

Sweet Potato Fries

Love these!

Mwright about 2 months ago

chicken, steak, shrimp, veggie, or surf-n-turf (steak and shrimp)

I crave the chicken broth bowl with rice noodles... in fact ordering it tonight for dinner! The savory broth is so delicious; warms the soul.

Theresa 2 months ago

Crab Cakes

The best crab cakes!! Service is always great,

Nyskate585 3 months ago

Grilled chicken, Sauted veggie, Slow roasted pork, Shaved steak, Brisket, Grilled shrimp, or Grilled Aukra Salmon

Grilled veggie burrito is sooooo good. It's massive too!

Anglirob 3 months ago

Grilled chicken, Sauted veggie, Slow roasted pork, Shaved steak, Brisket, Grilled shrimp, or Grilled Aukra Salmon

The rice bowl is my all-time favorite dish at this wonderful restaurant! The food is always tops & the service is outstanding. I love to sit outdoors with my dog at my feet. People here couldn't be nicer. I'm delighted to hear it will be open all winter, too.

Anglirob 3 months ago

Crab Cakes

A favorite hearty nibble, when a big dinner is too much.

Levesque 3 months ago

Southerner

We absolutely love the Southerner!!!!

Julward 3 months ago

Cauli Wings

Best place in the Finger Lakes. Period. I hate to share this little gem with others.... but they deserve the recognition. Fresh food, new menu items all the time.... and absolutely adorable setting. Love it!

Stacyfalkman 3 months ago

Tuscan

The tuscsn pizza and any of the rice bowls are my go to favorites at MillCreek! The food is so fresh, sourced locally, and unbelievably delicious! You really cant go wrong with anything on their menu. However, above and beyond the quality of their food is the impeccable service, and sense of community and home that yiu get and feel while dinning there. Weather your a local or there during summer at tour cottage they treat you like family. Absolutely love the crew and food at Millcreek!!

Sdudkiewicz 3 months ago

Cauli Wings

By far the cauliflower wings are my favourite dish on the menu! Tender cauliflower, crunchiest batter, amazingly spicy (but not too spicy) wing sauce, and a little blue cheese to cool it all down The best!

Arbyfries25 8 days ago

Poutine

It's so delicious, makes you feel like you are in Canada eating.

Loulou 10 days ago

Fried Chicken

The fried chicken sandwich is my cryptonite. I want to order other things on the menu.... but.... the fried chicken sandwich is too good. Mill Creek is a fabulous place that straddles the need for good comfort food and good bistro food. The staff is AMAZING. The beer and wine is good. Can't ask for more except maybe more tables on a busy night!

Maintainingtraction2 12 days ago

French Onion Soup

Delicious- comfort food in a cozy setting. One of my favorite items!

Tlexvold 13 days ago

Boneless Maryland Fried Chicken

These are fantastic as an appetizer or with another side as a meal! You can't go wrong with anything on the menu here...always the freshest ingredients and very imaginative specials too!

Tknopf 14 days ago

Grilled chicken, Sauted veggie, Slow roasted pork, Shaved steak, Brisket, Grilled shrimp, or Grilled Aukra Salmon

The rice bowl is amazing! Get it every time I go and the items are so fresh tasting

Bluegreenedragonfly 28 days ago

Cauli Wings

Sooo good! Vegetarians rejoice!

Linda about 1 month ago

Soy Maple Shrimp Salad

I am very fussy when it comes to restaurant food because I happened to marry a great cook! Loved it! Also absolutely love the atmosphere here. We live just outside Rochester and will come back whenever we are anywhere nearby.

Britt419smith about 1 month ago

Fried Chicken

The fried Chicken is so amazing. Crispy in the outside and juicy on the inside, never greasy! It's how it should be!

Kristie about 2 months ago

Poutine

Great! I can't wait to come back for more. Fish Fridays are my favorite.

Kristie about 2 months ago

Crab Cakes

Great taste but not enough to split

Mwright about 2 months ago

Eggplant Parmesan Stackers

So yummy! Crispy eggplant and a delicious, robust sauce.

Trenchie2day 3 months ago

Soy Maple Shrimp Salad

We also ordered the Salmon Burger and the Black Bean Burger with tomato soup on the side along with steak fries. Absolutely delicious!!!!! Every single bite of everything! Have been back several times, willingly driving an hour to get to the cafe. Highly recommend!

Nyskate585 3 months ago

Cauli Wings

Cali wings are amazing!!!

Anglirob 3 months ago

Southerner

A simple classic. Fresh & put together just right.

Anglirob 3 months ago

Eggplant Parmesan Stackers

Just thinking about this makes me smile! Generous enough to share. It's a favorite year 'round.

Kim 3 months ago

Sweet Potato Fries

My all-time favorite item on the menu is sweet potato fries. They are just the right crispiness and have a delightful seasoning salt on them. I order them every time I dine. Add woodstead sauce for dipping and I'm in heaven. Highly recommend you try it! :)

Donna 3 months ago

The Harvest

The Harvest salad is the best salad at I have in a long time. The Fish & Chip are one of the best.

Rusalka333 3 months ago

Boneless Maryland Fried Chicken

Anything you get at Mill Creek is going to be delicious, but the Maryland Chicken is my go-to. These guys fry it up perfectly, and the aioli is bangin'!



PAST DRAWING WINNERS

December:
Coming soon

November:
Courtney, Axe & Arrow
Seattle, WA

October:
Andy, Backwoods Brewing Co., Portland, OR

September:
Amanda, Home Restaurant, Los Angeles, CA

August:
Jennifer, Mark's City Grill - Columbus, GA

July:
Rebecca, Frank Gourmet - Buffalo, NY

June:
Donna, Dino's Sports Bar - Cape Cod, MA

May:
Karen, This Little Pig - Amherst, NY

April:
Alicia, Plant Based Pizzeria - Atlanta, GA