Add Your Review

Thanks for visiting Mill Creek Cafe. We'd love to have your feedback!


Don't remember the name of your dish? Find it on our menu!

Which dish or item did you try?

You are submitting your information to Mill Creek Cafe and Popmenu, which powers this site and is sponsoring this giveaway. By submitting, you agree to the Popmenu and .

Our Latest Reviews

Meghan about 1 month ago

Boneless Maryland Fried Chicken

The Maryland fried chicken sandwich was hands down the BEST sandwich I've ever had. The chicken was perfectly cooked, the sauce was bangin', and the sandwich was bigger than my face!

Elizabeth about 2 months ago

Bacon Cheeseburger

Amazing burger! Incredible sweet potato fries! Mill Creek's food is always "on point"!

Wnyghost 3 months ago

The Chicken Burrito

Our whole family loves the burritos and wraps. Great ingredients and fresh, generous portions. Staff is super friendly. We love visiting in all seasons.

Ericsonjm 3 months ago

Buff Chicken

Everything was so fresh, Buff Chicken was meaty and cooked perfectly, great sauce tasty fries, yummy slaw! Looking forward to trying more! Michelle

Germd92015 3 months ago

Panko Breaded Haddock

Best fish fry in the area I was reluctant to share this so next time we visit we can get an outside table in the back patio Excellent service and wine by the glass for me and IPA's for my husband A great find

Guest 3 months ago

grilled chicken

Everything was super tasty and enjoyed it very much. The only thing that I didn't like was the addition of mushrooms, as it isn't listed in the description and I don't eat them. Fortunately, it was piled on one side, rather than mixed throughout, so it was easy to remove. Perhaps, it was just an error by the person putting it together. Got it as a takeout.

Leanne 4 months ago

Fishermans Platter

Absolutely love Mill Creek! The food is amazing and fresh. The staff is so nice. I have also tried the Maryland fried chicken sandwich. Best fried chicken I have had in a long time!

Jenny 4 months ago

grilled chicken

Love this!! One of my favorites from Mill Creek.

Nyskate585 4 months ago

The Veggie Burrito

Excellent as always!

Yricht1 5 months ago

Panko Breaded Haddock

I love the fish fry! I love the cheesburgers, quesadillas, rice bowls, sweet potato fries, wraps! I have never had a meal at Mill Creek that I didn't like. I visit the restaurant often and take family and friends when they are in town for a visit. It's my favorite place to eat in Honeoye. No one has left there without being full and satisfied.......ever. Mmmmmm, mmmmmmm!

Juliemichmiller 5 months ago

grilled shrimp

This rice bowl is a true heaven sent. I can not count the number of mill creek rice bowls I have eaten in my life time. The shrimp? Untouchable. The guac? Give me a flipping break. It satisfies hunger, yes. But more than that it satisfies the HEART! I won't say it gives me the will to live, cause that would dramatic. But the days mill creek is closed are among my most challenging. BLESS UP MILL CREEK SHRIMP RICE BOWLS WITH GUAC! Cheers

Ann 6 months ago

Grilled chicken

One of my favorites!

Mari 6 months ago

Panko Breaded Haddock

Perfect 👌. I love mine with house chips or fries with malt vinegar ❤️❤️❤️

Carol 6 months ago

Sweet Potato Fries


Jyencer 8 months ago

Mill Creeks Turkey Chili

This was a FANTASTIC rich tasting chili! I've tried making it myself and nothing compares to this. You won't be disappointed!!

Scpestle 8 months ago

chicken, steak, shrimp, veggie, or surf-n-turf (steak and shrimp)

Their food is always wonderful! Great staff and I'm never disappointed.

Whitney 9 months ago

Grilled chicken, Sauted veggie, Shaved steak, Brisket, Grilled shrimp, or Grilled Aukra Salmon

I have recently fell in love with the Mediterranean Bowl. It's made perfectly everytime, even when I ask to have in made my way because I'm picky! They always are so kind and understanding each time I order! Amazing job guys! Keep it up!

Court 9 months ago

Patty Melt

The burger and flavor are just amazing. The sauce is a great mix and well balanced. The perfect baked sourdough tops everything off! We enjoyed it with french fries and loved the seasoning on those too.

Court 9 months ago

Mill Creeker Quesadilla

Another perfect menu item! The quesadilla is crispy, smokey, and savory with evenly spread ingredients throughout inside. I really loved the spinach touch, as I love adding it to my own homemade ones as well. The salsa and guacamole are also wonderful pairings for dipping or spreading.

Mimkenem 9 months ago

Veggie Veggie

Have been to your restaurant several times.. love all the veggie menu items. The Veggie Veggie wrap is one of my favorites. But I've enjoyed the Mediterranean Bowl and the Harvest Salad. It's one place I have recommended to several of my friends and all have enjoyed their visit and food. Atmosphere is very enjoyable. Looking forward to my next visit.

Coreycannonsd about 1 month ago

Blackened Surf-n-Turf

Salad was amazing service is even better!

Melissa 3 months ago

Mill Creeker Quesadilla

This quesadilla is delicious! Always a generous portion and filling. Must try with the homemade guacamole. My favorite item on the menu.

Guest 3 months ago

Buff Chicken

Everything was so fresh, Buff Chicken was meaty and cooked perfectly, great sauce tasty fries, yummy slaw! Looking forward to trying more! Michelle

Flowerfox420 3 months ago

Boneless Maryland Fried Chicken


Maintainingtraction2 3 months ago

Broiled Haddock

Delicious, fresh, perfectly cooked piece of fish! Yum!

Lindsaymickey 3 months ago

Cajun Bleu Burger

My mom and I had dinner there tonight and it was great, we brought our dog and sat on the patio. Andrea was our server and she was awesome. I had the special, the Reuben sandwich and it was delicious. A great end to a wonderful trip to Honeyoe Lake!

Jenny 4 months ago

Fried Chicken

Perfect every time.

Deamyers 4 months ago

Fishermans Platter

Everything was cooked to perfection! The shrimp was tender and flavorful, the fish was lightly fried just the way I would make it- only 10x better! I don't usually order sweet potato fries because I love the regular doused in ketchup-but the sweet potato fries were amazing-I'm a convert! Cannot wait to go back!

Brittany 5 months ago


Super yummy! Good proportions of everything on it.

Alissadixon 5 months ago

Korean Beef

My favorite! Every time I come up to the lake I go to MillCreek! Highly recommended!!

Mary 5 months ago

Sweet Potato Fries

What is the secret ingredient that makes these sweet potato fries better than any on the planet? I can't wait to come in and eat them again!

Greendae 6 months ago

Bacon Cheeseburger

By far the best burger in town! All of their ingredients are always fresh. Will definitely be back!

Carol 6 months ago

Guacamole and Fresh Tortilla Chips

One of my favorites

Joanne 6 months ago

Mill Creeker Quesadilla

I LOVE the Mill Creeker. It's grilled to perfection every time! It's delicious paired with a side of guacamole for dipping your quesadilla. I have even hooked my daughter on the Mill Creeker - it's so good! Mill Creek has so many wonderful choices for lunch and dinner.

Cpestle88 8 months ago

Grilled chicken, Sauted veggie, Shaved steak, Brisket, Grilled shrimp, or Grilled Aukra Salmon

Excellent as always!

Sydneyolivia716 9 months ago

Cauli Wings

This dish was the perfect Lenten Friday substitute and even enough to share! The cauliflower was crunchy and deliciously battered to taste just like a boneless wing. Might even try to trick my picky eater next visit. Delicious!

Guest 9 months ago

Sweet Potato Fries

No one has better sweet potato fries!!!

Court 9 months ago


Perfect! Extra crispy, thin cut french fries and thick delicious hot gravy!! The amount of cheese curds was also spot on. When I've ordered poutine at other restaurants there is often too many or too few.

Kbolcarovic 9 months ago

Quinoa Tabbouleh

Just tried this dish and LOVED it! Will be ording it more often!!!

Bridgetphughes 10 months ago

Blackened Surf-n-Turf

So good. I usually have to choose between steak or seafood on my salad and this had it all plus blue cheese! Can't ask for much more.


October 2020:
Charn, Vitaly
Costa Mesa, CA

September 2020:
Carol, Stroud's BBQ
Daytona Beach Shores, FL

August 2020:
Jo-El, Mick's All American
Mount Joy, PA 

July 2020:
Bronson, Los Dos Potrillos 

June 2020:
Elish, Crump's Landing
Homosassa, FL

May 2020:
Carlson, Papi Grande's Mexican
Amherst, NY

April 2020:
Sommer, Little Calf Creamery 
Thousand Oaks, CA

March 2020:
Theresa, Woody's Crab House
North East, MD

February 2020:
Maria, The Rustik Fork
Riverside, CA

January 2020:
Marsha, Stefano's Restaurant
Florence, SC

December 2019:
Alma, Karai Ramen Bistro
Jacksonville, FL

November 2019:
Courtney, Axe & Arrow
Seattle, WA

October 2019:
Andy, Backwoods Brewing Co.
Portland, OR

September 2019:
Amanda, Home Restaurant
Los Angeles, CA

August 2019:
Jennifer, Mark's City Grill
Columbus, GA

July 2019:
Rebecca, Frank Gourmet
Buffalo, NY

June 2019:
Donna, Dino's Sports Bar
Cape Cod, MA

May 2019:
Karen, This Little Pig
Amherst, NY

April 2019:
Alicia, Plant Based Pizzeria
Atlanta, GA